ON THE JUDEAN POLITICAL INDEPENDENCE IN THE PERIOD OF THE HASMONEANS
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.14795/j.v11i2.1015Keywords:
Hasmoneans, independence, John Hyrcanus I, autonomy, JudeaAbstract
The Hasmoneans were an effective power in the Judean region in the second half of the second century BC and the first half of the first century BC. In the sources that provide information about the period and the region, there are some statements indicating that the Hasmoneans had lead a politically independent political structure by separating from the Seleucid State at some point during the period of their presence in the region. In fact, scholars today agree that the Hasmoneans ruled an independent state in history. There even seems to be a consensus among contemporary scholars that this independence took place during the reign of John Hyrcanus I. However, when the massive literature on the Hasmonean State is examined, various opinions are encountered that the independence in question was established by different leaders of the dynasty. Despite this situation, the lack of a study that addresses the issue with a holistic approach has been noticed. For this reason, in this study, different views are presented, pointing to the political independence of the Hasmoneans. Afterwards, these views were discussed within the framework of the phenomenon of political independence in the Hellenistic period, the conceptual framework of which we tried to present. Finally, among the results of the study, the possible reasons for the existing different views are pointed out and a relatively new argument is presented, indicating that the political independence of the Hasmonean State took place during the reign of Hyrcanus I, through literary sources, numismatic works and archaeological findings.
Downloads
References
MACC.
Schwartz, D., 1 Maccabees. A New Translation with Introduction and Commentary (New Haven: Yale University Press) (2022).
MACC.
Schwartz, D., 2 Maccabees (Berlin: Walter de Gruyter) (2008).
AITKEN 2011
Aitken, J. K., Judaic National Identity. In: Grabbe, L./Lipschits, O. (eds.), Judah between East and West, the Transition from Persian to Greek Rule (ca. 400–200 BCE), (London: Bloomsbury Publishing), 31–48.
ALLEGRO 2015
Allegro, J. M., The Chosen people, A study of Jewish History from the Time of the Exile Until the Revolt of Bar Kochba (Ohio: Rousseau).
APP. MITH.
White, H., Appian’s Roman History Books VIII Part II – XII 2 (Great Britain: Loeb Classical Library) (1962).
APP. SYR.
White, H., Appian’s Roman History Books VIII Part II – XII 2 (Great Britain: Loeb Classical Library) (1962).
ARIEL 2021
Ariel, D., John Hyrcanus I’s First Autonomous Coins. In: Berlin, M./Kosmin, A. M. (eds.), The Middle Maccabees, Archaeology, History and the Rise of the Hasmonean Kingdom (Atlanta: SBL Press), 215–242.
ATKINSON 2016
Atkinson, K., A History of Hasmonean State, Josephus and Beyond (London: Bloomsbury).
BABYLONIAN TALMUD
Babylonian Talmud, https://www.sefaria.org/texts/Talmud. Accesed 12 July 2023.
BARON 1952
Baron, S. W., A Social and Religious History of the Jews I (New York: Columbia University Press).
BERRY 2010
Berry, G. R., Classic Greek Dictionary (USA: Gorgias Press).
BERTHELOT 2018
Berthelot, K., In Search of the Promised Land? (Göttingen: Vandenhoeck&Ruprecht).
BEVAN 1902
Bevan, E. R., The House of Seleucus II (London: Edward Arnold).
BICKERMAN 1962
Bickerman, E., From Ezra to the Last of the Maccabees Foundations of Post-Biblical Judaism (New York: Shocken Books).
BT. KIDDUSHIN
Bt. Kiddushin, Text and translation from sefaria.org
BT. ROSH HASHANAH
Bt. Rosh Hashanah, Text and translation from sefaria.org
COHEN 2014
Cohen, S. J. D., From the Maccabees to the Mishnah (Kentucky: Westminister John Knox Press).
CONDER 1879
Conder, C. R., Judas Maccabaeus and the Jewish War of Independence (London: Marcus Ward&Co.).
COŞKUN 2018
Coşkun, A., The Liberation of Judaea and Early Maccabaean Diplomacy with Rome according to Justin (36.3.9), Diodorus (40.2/4) and Caesar (Jos. Ant. Jud. 14.10.6 [205]), Anabasis Studia Classica Et Orientalia 9, 181–203.
COŞKUN 2021
Coşkun, A., John Hyrkanos I, Antiochos VII and the Siege of Jerusalem (135–134 BC). In: Feyel, C./Graslin-Thomé, L. (eds.), Les Derniers Séleucides et leur Territoire (Paris: Editions de Boccard), 185–230.
COŞKUN 2021a
Coşkun, A., Seleucid Throne Wars: Resilience and Disintegration of the Greatest Successor Kingdom from Demetrius I to Antiochus VII. In Berlin, A. M./Kosmin, P. J. (ed.), The Middle Maccabees, Archaeology, History and the Rise of the Hasmonean Kingdom (Atlanta: SBL Press), 269–292.
COŞKUN 2022
Coşkun, A., The Reception of Seleukid Ideology in Second-Century BCE Judea. In: Anagnostou-Laoutides, E./Pfeiffer, S. (eds.), Culture and Ideology under the Seleukids (Berlin-Boston: De Gruyter), 151–166.
DABROWA 2010
Dabrowa, E., The Hasmoneans and their State, A Study in History, Ideology and the Institutions (Krakow: Jagiellonian University Press).
DIOD.
Walton, F. R., Diodorus of Sicily, Fragments of Books XXXIII – XL 12 (London: William Heinemann Ltd., 1984).
ECKHARDT 2016
Eckhardt, B., The Hasmoneans and their Rivals in Seleucid and Post-Seleucid Judea, The Journal for the Study of Judaism in the Persian, Hellenistic and Roman Period 47, 55–70.
ESHEL 2008
Eshel, H., The Dead Sea Scrolls and the Hasmonean State (Israel: Yad – Ben Zvi Press).
FINKIELSZTEJN 1998
Finkielsztejn, G., More Evidence on John Hyrcanus I’s Conquest: Lead Weights and Rhodian Amphora Stamps, Bulletin of the Anglo-Israel Archaeological Society 16, 33–63.
FREEMAN 2013
Freeman, C., Mısır, Yunan ve Roma Antik Akdeniz Uygarlıkları (trans. Angı, S.K) (Ankara: Dost Kitabevi).
GOLDSTEIN 2007
Goldstein, J., The Hasmonean Revolt and the Hasmonean Dynasty. In Davies, D./Finkelstein, L. (eds.), The Cambridge History of Judaism, The Hellenistic Age 2 (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press), 292–351.
GOODMAN 2007
Goodman, M., Rome and Jerusalem; The Clash of Ancient Civilizations (New York: Alfred A. Knopf).
GRABBE 2010
Grabbe, L., An Introduction to Second Temple Judaism; History and Religion of the Jews in the Time of Nehemiah, the Maccabees, Hillel and Jesus (London: T&T Clark).
GRAETZ 1891
Graetz, H., History of the Jews, from the Earliest Period to the Death of Simon the Maccabee 1 (Philadelphia: The Jewish Publication Society of America).
GRAYZEL 1968
Grayzel, S., A History of the Jews, From the Destruction of Judah in 586 BC to the Present Arab – Israeli Conflict (Philadelphia: The Jewish Publication Society of America).
HENDIN 2007–2008
Hendin, D., Numismatic Expressions of Hasmonean Sovereignty, Israel Numismatic Journal 16, 76–91.
HENDIN 2021
Hendin, D., Guide to Biblical Coins (New York: American Numismatic Society).
HENGEL 1980
Hengel, M., Jews, Greeks and Barbarians (Philadelphia: Fortress Press).
HOOVER 2003
Hoover, O., The Seleucid Coinage of John Hyrcanus I: The Transformation of a Dynastic Symbol in Hellenistic Judea, American Journal of Numismatics 15, 29–40.
HORNBLOWER 2012
Hornblower, S., Autonomy. In: Hornblower, S./Spawforth, A. (eds.), The Oxford Classical Dictionary (Oxford: Oxford University Press), 214.
HORSLEY 2009
Horsley, R., The Expansion of Hasmonean Rule in Idumea and Galilee Toward a Historical Sociology. In: Davies, P. R./Halligan, J. M. (eds.), Second Temple Studies, Studies in Politics, Class and Material Culture 3 (Sheffield: Sheffield Academic Press), 134–165.
JOSEPH. AJ.
Marcus, R., Josephus, Jewish Antiquities Books XII–XIV 7 (London: William Heinemann Ltd., 1957).
JOSEPH. BJ.
Thackeray, H. J., Josephus, The Jewish Wars I–III 2 (London: William Heinemann Ltd., 1956).
JUST. EPIT.
Yardley, J. C., Epitome of the Philippic History of Pompeius Trogus (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1994).
KLAUSNER 1972
Klausner, J., John Hyrcanus I. In: Schalit, A. (ed.), The Hellenistic Age, Political History of Jewish Palestine from 332 BCE to 67 BCE (New Brunswick: Rutgers University Press), 211–221.
KLAUSNER 1972a
Klausner, J., The First Hasmonean Rulers Jonathan and Simeon. In: Schalit, A. (ed.), The Hellenistic Age, Political History of Jewish Palestine from 332 BCE to 67 BCE (New Brunswick: Rutgers University Press), 183–210.
KOSMIN 2014
Kosmin, P., The Land of the Elephant Kings, Space, Territory and Ideology in the Seleucid Empire (Cambridge, Massachusetts-London, England: Harvard University Press).
KRATZ 2015
Kratz, R. G., Historical & Biblical Israel the History, Tradition and Archives of Israel and Judah (Oxford: Oxford University Press).
LEVINE 1998
Levine, L. I., Judaism & Hellenism in Antiquity, Conflict or Confluence? (Seattle: University of Washington Press).
MADDEN 1881
Madden, F., Coins of the Jews (London: Trübner & Co.).
MAGNESS 2012
Magness, J., The Archaeology of the Holy Land from the Destruction of Solomon’s Temple to Muslim Conquest (New York: Cambridge University Press).
MARGOLIS/MARX 1945
Margolis, M. L./Marx A., A History of the Jewish People (Philadelphia: Jewish Publication Society of America).
MEIR 2023
Meir, R. A., Honor the King, and his Friends: The Extent of Early Hasmonean. In: Krüger, D./Kloztbach, C. M./Pfeilschiefter, R. (eds.), Local Self-governance in Antiquity and in the
Global South (Berlin: De Gruyter), 133–158.
MESHORER 2001
Meshorer, Y., A Treasury of Jewish Coins (Jerusalem: Yad – Ben Zvi Press).
MEYERS/CHANCEY 2012
Meyers, E. M./Chancey, M. A., Archaeology of the Land of the Bible from Alexander to Constantine 3 (New Haven-London: Yale University Press).
MILMAN 1913
Milman, H. H., The History of the Jews 1 (London: J. M. Dent&Sons Ltd.).
MISHNAH
Mishnah, https://www.sefaria.org/texts/Mishnah. Accesed 15 July 2023.
MURRAY 2012
Murray, O., Kingship. In: Hornblower, S./Spawforth, A. (eds.), The Oxford Classical Dictionary (Oxford: Oxford University Press), 785.
NANA 2008
Nana, M., Yahudi Tarihi (İstanbul: Selenge Yayınları).
OTTLEY 1901
Ottley, R. L., A Short History of the Hebrews, to the Roman Empire (New York: The Macmillan Company).
PERDUE/CARTER 2015
Perdue, L. G./Carter, W., Israel and Empire a Postcolonial History of Israel and Early Judaism (London-New York: Bloomsbury).
RAJAK 2001
Rajak, T., The Jewish Dialogue with Greeks and Rome (Leiden: Brill).
RAPPAPORT 2012
Rappaport, U., 1 Maccabees. In: Goodman, M. (ed.), The Apochrypha (Oxford: Oxford University Press).
REGEV 2013
Regev, E., The Hasmoneans, Ideology, Archaeology, Identity (Göttingen: Vandenhock&Ruprecht).
SCHÄFER 2003
Schäfer, P., The History of the Jews in the Greco – Roman World (London: Routledge).
SCHÜRER 1890
Schürer, E., A History of Jewish People in the Time of Jesus Christ 1 (Edinburgh: T&T Clark).
SCHÜRER 1973
Schürer, E., The History of the Jewish People in the Age of Jesus Christ (Edinburgh: T&T Clark).
SCHWARTZ 2014
Schwartz, S., The Ancient Jews from Alexander to Muhammad (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press).
SHATZMAN 1999
Shatzman, I., The Integration of Judea into the Roman Empire, Scripta Clasicca Israelica 18, 49–84.
SHATZMAN 2012
Shatzman, I., The Expansionist Policy of John Hyrcanus and His Relations with Rome. In: Urso, G. (ed.), Iudaea Socıa-Iudaea Capta (Pisa: Edizioni ETS), 29–78.
SMALLWOOD 1976
Smallwood, M., The Jews Under Roman Rule, From Pompey to Diocletian (Leiden: Brill).
STERN 1976
Stern, M., The Period of the Second Temple. In: Ben-Sasson, H. H. (ed.), A History of the Jewish People (Cambridge, Massachusetts: Harvard University Press), 185–306.
STRAB.
Jones, H. L., The Geography of Strabo 4,7 (London: William Heinemann Ltd.) (1960&1930).
TCHERIKOVER 1959
Tcherikover, V. A., Hellenistic Civilization and The Jews (Philadelphia: The Jewish Publication Society of America).
TRAMPEDACH 2012
Trampedach, K., The War of the Hasmoneans. In: Signori, G. (ed.), Dying for the Faith, Killing for the Faith, Old Testament Faith Warriors (1 and 2 Maccabees) in Historical Perspective (Leiden: Brill), 39–60.
VANDERKAM 2004
Vanderkam, J., From Joshua to Caiaphas High Priests After Exile (Minneapolis: Fortress Press).
WHITE 1962
White, H., Appian’s Roman History Books VIII Part II – XII 2 (Great Britain: Loeb Classical Library).
WOODHOUSE 1910
Woodhouse, S. C., English-Greek Dictionary A Vocabulary of the Attic Language (London: George Routledge&Sons).
ZEITLIN 1968
Zeitlin, S., The Rise and Fall of Judean State, A Political, Social and Religious History of the Second Commonwealth 1 (Philadelphia: The Jewish Publication Society of America).
Downloads
Additional Files
Published
Issue
Section
License
Authors who publish with this journal agree to the following terms:
- Authors retain copyright and grant the journal right of first publication with the work simultaneously licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution License that allows others to share the work with an acknowledgement of the work's authorship and initial publication in this journal, we use CC BY-NC-ND license (Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs) wich only allowing others to download your works and share them with others as long as they credit you, but they can’t change them in any way or use them commercially.
- Authors are able to enter into separate, additional contractual arrangements for the non-exclusive distribution of the journal's published version of the work (e.g., post it to an institutional repository or publish it in a book), with an acknowledgement of its initial publication in this journal.
- Authors are permitted and encouraged to post their work online (e.g., in institutional repositories or on their website) prior to and during the submission process, as it can lead to productive exchanges, as well as earlier and greater citation of published work (See The Effect of Open Access).
