DETERMINING THE OPTIMAL SETTLEMENT LOCATING OF ANCIENT SITES USING TOPSIS MULTI-CRITERIA DECISION MODEL: A CASE STUDY: ESTABLISHMENTS IN MOUNTAINOUS AREAS OF NORTH KHORASAN, NORTHEAST IRAN

Authors

  • Mohsen Heydari DASTENAEI Department of Archeology, Faculty of Archeology, Shahid Chamran University of Ahvaz, Ahvaz, Iran.
  • Mohsen DANA Ministry of Cultural Heritage, Handicrafts and Tourism, Tehran, Iran (RICHT).

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.14795/j.v10i1.787

Keywords:

Optimal settlement locating, ancient sites, TOPSIS multi-criteria decision-making, mountainous areas, northeast Iran

Abstract

Human settlements emerged based on natural factors such as adequate water resources and suitable and fertile soil. Other factors such as altitude, slope, and slope direction, the distance to permanent water sources, and communication paths are natural substrates that affect the distribution of human settlements, some of which have a more influential role in the formation and survival of life. This study aims to investigate the status of the Iron Age settlement in the Atrak River Basin. To achieve the objectives of the research and hierarchical analysis of Iron Age sites, seven natural variables, including altitude, slope, slope direction, landing, soil type, distance to rivers, and communication routes that have been effective in establishing settlements, have been selected and by using the statistical methods in the GIS, the TOPSIS hierarchical analysis process, and Excel, and they finally been studied. In terms of statistical analysis, the distance from river, Landuse and the distance to communication routes have been assigned the most ideal values.  The slope degree, above sea level and Slope Direction have the lowest ideal value, respectively. Based on this, the IAMA60 site ranked first, the IAMA49 site ranked second, and the IAMA18 site ranked third in terms of natural indicators. In the lowest rank, IAMA25, IAMA35, and IAMA56 sites are located. In addition to these, the rest of the sites are considered relatively privileged areas.

Downloads

Download data is not yet available.

References

ALDENDERFER 1998

Aldenderfer, M., Quantitative Methods in Archaeology: A Review of Recent Trends and Developments, Journal of Archaeological Research 6/2, 91-120. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF02446161.

ADAM 1981

Adams, R. Mc., Heartland of Cities: Surveys of Ancient Settlement and Landuse on the Central Floodplain of Euphrates (Chicago: University of Chicago Press).

ADINEH 2012

Adine, O., Soundings for determination boundery at Tappe Boruski, Ashkhane, Northern Khorasan, Abstract. In: The 11th Annual Symposium of Iranian Archaeology (Tehran: Cultural Heritage Research Institute), 53.

AFIFI 2018

Afifi, M. E., Analyze the Impact of Natural Factors in the Spatial Distribution of Urban and Rural Settlements of Khonj County, Journal of Studies of Human Settlement Planning 13/3, 629-646.

AKBAR AGHALLI/VELAYATI 2007

Akbar Aghalli, F./Velayati, S., Investigating the position of natural factors in the establishment of rural settlements. Geography, International and Scientific Journal of Iranian Geography Association 12-13, 45-66.

ANABESTANI 2011

Anabestani, A. A., The Role of Natural Factors in Stability of Rural Settlements (Case Study: Sabzevar Country), Geography and Environmental Planning 40/4, 89-104.

ATAEI 2009

Ataei, T., Report on Archaeological Surveys in Mane & Samalghan County (Nrthern Khorasan), Frist Season (Tehran: ICAR. Unpublished).

Ates et alii 2006

Ates, N. Y./Cevik, S./Kahraman, C./Gulbay, M./Erdogan, S. A., Multi attribute performance evaluation using a hierarchical fuzzy TOPSIS method. In: Kahraman, C. (ed.), Fuzzy Applications in Industrial Engineering (Berlin/Heidelberg: Springer), 537-572.

BEHZAD/ASADIAN 2017

Behzad, A., Asadian, F., Impact of environmental factors on destruction of archaeological sites by TOPSIS model (case study archaeological sites of Darreh Shahr and Abdanan of Ilam province). Territory 14/53, 1-20.

CHEN 2000

Chen, C. T., Extensions of the TOPSIS for group decision-making under fuzzy Environment, Fuzzy Sets and Systems 114, 1–9. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0165-0114(97)00377-1.

COATES/JOHN STON/KNOX 1977

Coates, B. E./Johnston, R. J./Knox, P. L., Geography and inequality (Oxford: Oxford University Press).

DANA/HEJEBRI NOBARI 2018

Dana, M./Hejebri Nobari, A., Site Formation Process as Seen from Tpe Bimarestan-e Ashkhane Excavations Data, Journal of Archaeological Studies 10/2, 83-97. https://doi.org/10.22059/jarcs.2019.68527.

DANA/HEJEBRI NOBARI/MOUSAVI KOUHPAR 2020

Dana, M./Hejebri Nobari, A./Mousavi Kouhpar, M., Excavation at Tappe Bimarestan Ashkhaneh; an Iron Age Graveyard in the North of Khorasan, Archäologische Mitteilungen aus Iran und Turan 49, 151-167.

DANA/HEJEBRI/RAHMATI 2018

Dana, M./Hozhabri, A./Rahmati, M., Kohne Kand Bojnord, a Parthian Site with local caracteres in North Khorasan. In: Aziziz Kharanaghim, M.H., Khanipour, M., Naseri, R. (eds.), Second International Symposium of Young Archaeologists 2 (Theran: Iranology Fondation), 795-834.

DENG/YEH/WILLIS 2000

Deng, H./Yeh, C.H./Willis, R.J., Inter-company comparison using modified TOPSIS with objective weights, Computers & Operations Research 27/10, 963-973. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0305-0548(99)00069-6.

DUCKSTEIN/FOGEL/THAMES 1973

Duckstein, L./Fogel, M./Thames, J. L., Elevation effects on rainfall: A stochastic model, Journal of Hydrology 18/1, 21-35. https://doi.org/10.1016/0022-1694(73)90023-1.

ESTELAJI/GHADIRI MASOUM 1995

Eselaji, A./Ghadiri Masoum, M., Investigating Geographical Factors in the System of Rural Settlements with Emphasis on Quantitative Techniques (Case Study: Wilkij District of Namin County), Journal of Geographical Researches 37/53, 121-136.

GARAZHIAN 2007

Garazhian, O., Report on Surface Surveys of Samalghan Plain, Northern Khorasan (Tehran: ICAR Unpublished) [In Persian].

GARAZHIAN 2011

Garazhian, O., Sunding for Stratigraphy and Documentation of Architectural Remains of Tappe Qal’e Khan, Mane and Samalghan County, Northern Khorasan Province. In: The 9th Annual Symposium on Iranian Archaeology (Tehran: ICAR), 145- 159.

GARAZHIAN/ASKARPUR 2011

Garazhian, E./Askarpur, V., Trends in Evolution of Pottery in Qal’eh Khān, Bojnūrd, Journal of Archaeological Studies 3/1, 107- 132.

GARAZHIAN/JAFARI/HOZHABRI 2011

Garazhian, O./Jafari, J./Hozhabri, A., Report of Archaeological Researches for Documentation of Architectures at Tappe Qal’e Khan, Khorasan, emphasis on the Historical Period, Modares Archaeological Research 3, 161- 199.

GARAZHIAN/PAPOLI YAZDI/FAKHR-E GHASEMI 2014

Garazhian, O./Papoli Yazdi, L./Fakhr-e Ghaemi, H., Qaleh Khan a Site in Northern Khorassan and the Neolithic of North Eastern Iranian Plateau, Archäologische Mitteilungen aus Iran und Turan 46, 21-50.

GHOLAMI RAD/SHARIATPANAH 2014

Gholami Rad, Z./Shariatpanah, M., Investigating the position of natural factors in the establishment of rural settlements in Kermanshah province based on AHP hierarchical analysis process model using GIS, Geographical territory 10/37, 55-76.

HAMBRECHT et alii 2020

Hambrecht, G./Anderung, C./Brewington, S./Dugmore, A./Edvardsson, R./Feeley, F./Gibbons, K./Harrison, R./Hicks, M./Jackson, R./Ólafsdóttir, G. Á./Rockman, M./Smiarowski, K./Streeter, R./Szabo, V./McGovern, T., Archaeological sites as Distributed Long-term Observing Networks of the Past (DONOP), Quaternary International 549, 218-226. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.quaint.2018.04.016.

HEJEBRI NOBARI/BISIONE/JUDY 2021

Hejebri Nobari, A./Biscione, R./Judy, N., Settlement Patterns of the Bronze Age Sites of the Upper and Middle Atrak Basin in the Northeast of Iran, Journal of Archaeological Studies 13/2, 293- 317. https://doi.org/10.22059/jarcs.2021.279390.142703.

HEYDARI DASTENAEI 2018

Heydari Dastenaei, M., 2018. The effect of environmental factors on the Prehistoric sites in the southern Zayandeh- Rud by using the Pearson correlation, Journal of Iran Pre-Islamic Archaeological Essays 2/1, 1-14.

HEYDARI DASTENAEI/NIKNAMI 2020

Heydari Dastenaei, M./Niknami. K. A., Analysis Of The Relationship Between The Formation And Continuity Of Neolithic Period Settlements With Their Environment In The Sarfirouz Abad Plain Of Kermanshah, West Central Zagross, Physical Geography Research Quarterly 56/2, 313-331. https://doi.org/10.22059/jphgr.2020.285488.1007418.

HWANG/YOON 1981

Hwang, C.L./Yoon, K., Multiple attributes decision making methods and applications (Berlin: Springer).

JAFARI/THOMALSKY 2016

Jafari, J., Thomalsky, J., The Iranian-German Tappe Rivi Project (TRP), North-Khorasan: Report on the 2016 and 2017 Fieldworks, Archäologische Mitteilungen aus Iran und Turan 48, 77-120.

KARAM/SAFA KISH/KIANI 2014

Karam, A./Safa Kish, F./Kiani, T., Locate and Prioritize potential sites to physical development using hierarchical approach (TOPSIS) and Geographical Information System (GIS) (Case Study: Daryon City), Applied Geomorphology of Iran 2/3, 47-64.

MAGAS/GAJSKI/DZIEGIELEWSKA-GAJSKI 2021

Magaš, L./Gajski, D./Dzięgielewska-Gajski, K., Spatial multi criteria Approach to the evaluation of Archaeological Sites, GIS Odyssey Journal 1/1, 21–35. DOI: https://doi.org/10.57599/gisoj.2021.1.1.21.

MAGHSOUDI et alii 2020

Maghsoudi, M./Fazeli Nashli, H./Azizi, Gh./Gillmore, G./Scmit, A., Geoarchaeology of Alluvial Fans: A Case Study from Jajroud and Hajiarab Alluvial Fans in Iran, Physical Geography Research Quarterly 44 /4, 1-22. https://doi.org/ 10.22059/jphgr.2012.30239.

MIRZAEI 2008

Mirzaei, A., Report on Surface Surveys in Faruj and Shirvan County, Northern Khorasan (Tehran: ICAR, Unpublished) [In Persian].

MOTARJEM/SIASAR 2017

Motarjem, A./Siasar, N., Studying the Changes of Distribution Patterns of the Bronze and Iron Ages Settlements in Chamchamal Plain, Central Zagros, Pazhuhesh-ha-ye Bastanshenasi Iran 6/11, 75-90. https://doi.org/10.22084/nbsh.2016.1740.

NAMI/MOUSAVINIA 2019

Nami, H./Mousavinia, S. M., Archaeological Survey of Parthian Sites in Dargaz Plain, North-East of Iran, Pazhuhesh-ha-ye Bastanshenasi Iran 11, 233- 252. https://doi.org/10.22059/jarcs.2019.71116.

NEMATI/RAMESHT 2022

Nematollahi, F./Ramesht, M. H., Spatial Analysis of Irans’ Rural Settlement, Geography and Development 65/19, 1-26. https://doi.org/10.22111/j10.22111.2021.6519.

NOORI et alii 2011

Noori, R./Jafari, F./Asgharzadeh, F./Akbarzadeh, A., Offering a Proper Framework to Investigate Water Quality of the Atrak River, Iranian Journal of Health and Environment 4/2, 159-170.

QAZANFARPOUR/KAMANDARI/MOHAMMAD SOLEYMANI 2013

Qazanfarpour, H./Kamandari, M./Mohammadi Soleymani, M., The effect of geographical factors on the pattern of rural housing in Kerman province, Zagros Landscape Geography and Urban Planning Quarterly 5/18, 125-142.

RAJABI 2013

Rajabi, N., The Final Report on Archaeological Surveys in Bojnord and Raz & Jargalan County, Northern Khorasan (Tehran: ICAR. Unpublished) [In Persian].

RAHIMI/HASANPOUR 2011

Rahimi, M.L./Hasanpour, Kh., Location finding of a new village in Bastak province considering passive defense in GIS environment using AHP model, Journal of Hormozgan Caltural 1/1-2, 12-26.

SADR MOUSAVI/TALEBIFAR/NIAZY 2018

Sadr Mousavi, M./Talebifard, R./Niazy, Ch., Investigating the Role of Natural Factors in the Geographical Distribution of Rural Settlements (Case Study: Sahneh County), Journal of Studies of Human Settlement Planning 12/4, 731-749.

SALMANPOUR/SENMAR/BAKHTIARVAND BAKHTIARI 2013

Salmanpour, A./Senmar, M./Bakhtiavand Bakhtiari, A., The role of soil on archaeological analysis and studies. In: The First Symposium of Archaeology of Iran (Birjand) [In Persian].

SHEIKHVAHED/BAHREMAND/MUSHEKHIAN 2011

Sheikhvahed, B./Bahremand, A./Mushekhian, Y., A Comparison of Trends in Hydrologic Variables in the Atrak River Basin Using Non-parametric Trend Analysis Tests, Journal of Water and Soil Conservation 18/2, 1-23.

VAHDATI 2014

Vahdati, A. A., A BMAC Grave from Bojnord, North-Eastern Iran, Iran 52, 19-27. https://doi.org/10.1080/05786967.2014.11834735.

VOGEL 1986

Vogel, J., Subsistence settlement systems in the prehistory of south western Zambia, Human Ecology 14, 397–414. https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00888306.

VOSOGH BABAEI/MEHRAFARIN 2018

Vosogh Babaei, E./Mehrafarin, R., Analysing the Role of Environmen in the Parthian Settlements Distribution: A Case Study in the Chelchay River Drainage, Minodasht, Golestan, Iran, Pazhuhesh-ha-ye Bastanshenasi Iran 16, 183-202. https://doi.org/10.22084/nbsh.2018.14420.1635.

WANG et alii 2020

Wang, Z./Wang, C./Jiang, Z./Hu, T./Han, W./Zhang, C./Jin, J./Wei, K./Zhao, J./Wang, X., Relationship between Rural Settlements’ Plant Communities and Environmental Factors in Hilly Area of Southeast China, Sustainability 12/2771, 1-17. https://doi.org/10.3390/su12072771.

YAMANI/DOLATI/ZAREI 2010

Yamani, M./Dolati, J./Zarei, A., The effect of hydrogeomorphic factors on temporal and spatial changes in the middle part of the Atrak River, Geographical Researches 99, 1-24.

YARMOHAMADI/SHARAFI 2016

Yarahmadi, D./Sharafi, S., Environmental factors affecting the formation and occurrence of natural hazards rural settlements Silakhor Plains in Lorestan Province, Journal of Natural Environmental Hazards 5/8 L, 123-134. https://doi.org/10.22111/jneh.2016.2865.

YAU 2009

Yau, Y., Multi-criteria decision making for urban built heritage conservation: application of the analytic hierarchy process, Journal of Building Appraisal 4/3, 191-205. https://doi.org/10.1057/jba.2008.34.

YAZDANI 2015

Yazdani, A., Soundings for determination boundery at Kalate Mostowfi (Bojnord, Iron Age), (Tehran: ICAR, Unpublished) [In Persian].

ZARE 2011

Zare, Sh., Report on Archaeological Surveys in Mane & Samalghan County (Northern Khorasan). Second Season (Tehran: ICAR, Unpublished) [in Persian].

ZHANG et alii 2014

Zhang, Zh./Xiao, R./Shortridge, A./Wu, J., Spatial Point Pattern Analysis of Human Settlements and Geographical Associations in Eastern Coastal China — A Case Study, International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health 11/3, 2818-2833. https://doi.org/10.3390/ijerph110302818.

ZOMORRODIAN 1995

Zomorrodian, M. J., Application of natural geography in urban and rural planning (Tehran: Payam Nur Publications).

Downloads

Additional Files

Published

2023-05-01

Issue

Section

Archaeology

How to Cite

DETERMINING THE OPTIMAL SETTLEMENT LOCATING OF ANCIENT SITES USING TOPSIS MULTI-CRITERIA DECISION MODEL: A CASE STUDY: ESTABLISHMENTS IN MOUNTAINOUS AREAS OF NORTH KHORASAN, NORTHEAST IRAN. (2023). JOURNAL OF ANCIENT HISTORY AND ARCHAEOLOGY, 10(1). https://doi.org/10.14795/j.v10i1.787

Similar Articles

1-10 of 369

You may also start an advanced similarity search for this article.